Beati hispani quibus vivere est bibere. Lucky the Spaniards, for whom living is drinking
"Lucky the Spaniards, for whom living is drinking" - A reference to the Spanish pronunciation of Latin, in which "v" (“vivere”) was pronounced as "b" (“bibere”).
This is a funny Latin saying that has had remarkable success. It bases its strength, or comic "vis", on the fact that the words "vivere" and "bibere" sound exactly the same because in the Spanish pronunciation of Latin the sounds [b] and [v] are not distinguished.
You have to know that in classical Latin the "v" sounded like "u", that is, like the English / w /, and the "b" sometimes as plosive labial / b / and others as fricative voiced bilabial / v /, so at that time the confusion was impossible.
Related to this, although different, is the phonetic evolution by which, on one hand, the / b / (plosive voiced labial) became fricative in intervocalic position and, on the other hand, the semivowel / w / (that was the sound of the V or u) also becomes fricative.
These phonetic changes probably took place as early as the first century AD. This coincidence of / b / and / v / is called “betacismus” and it is common in the language of Oc (French Occitan), in Castilian, Basque, in much of Catalan and Galician and in northern Portuguese; and it also happened in Greek.
As a result of all this the orthographic confusion in the use of "b" and "v" has been very common since Antiquity, being especially accentuated in Hispania from Visigothic times and throughout the Middle Ages, although later etymology fixed the current spelling.
Thus in Visigothic manuscripts the graphic confusion between “vivere” and “bibere” is frequent. In the Emilian Glosses, considered the oldest document in Castilian or Spanish (the oldest texts of the “Valpuesta” Monastery, in Álava, in the Basque Country, do not seem to deserve this title) we read (“sanos et salbos”) ("healthy and saved") (from Latin salvus) or alquandas beces (in Spanish algunas veces) (from Latin vicis= shifts, times, sometimes) or salbatore and serbitjio in the famous gloss number 89. We could cite Berceo or Verceo and his "plain language"="En qual suele el pueblo fablar a su becino” /en el cual suele el pueblo hablar a su vecino/ (“in which people vse to talk to their neighbours”) and many other documents.
In modern times the “betacismus” is one of the main features of Castilian and of Gascon, Euskera or Basque, although the etymology has established the original orthography, as we said.
On the success of the expression or saying we're talking about we must also take into account the idea, unscientific as it is, that Spaniards (Spanish people) drink a lot or that many of them are drinkers who drink more than other nearby people. It is not uncommon to read or hear news where, with a critical but well-meaning point of view or with an idiot satisfaction of believing as if we are setting a record somehow, it is stated that Spain is the EU country with the most bars.
This expression (beati hispani quibus vivere est bibere), as it has been transcribed, is anonymous or at least the father of this saying hasn't been found.
The phrase, as it has been transcribed, is anonymous or at least its father has not been identified, but its meaning, or the wit involved in relating living with drinking wine, is very old. As evidence, take the fact that Athenaeus, a Greek grammarian, rhetorician and erudite , who lived in the second century AD, under the emperor Marcus Aurelius, in his book " The Deipnosophistae, or Banquet of the learned, 22F" quotes a passage from the playwright Antiphanes , who lived between 408 and 334 BC, which reads:
To live, tell me,
What is it? I say it is to drink.
Τὸ δὲ ζῆν, εἰπέ μοι,
τί ἐστι; τὸ πίνειν φήμ´ ἐγώ.
There have been some people who (without any evidence) have attributed to the poet Martial (Marcus Valerius Martialis) (40-104), who was born in Bilbilis, near present-day Calatayud, in the province of Zaragoza, the following couplet:
Haud temere antiquas mutat Vasconia voces
Cui nihil est aliud vivere quam bibere
Without fear the Basque Country changes the old voices
for whom there's no difference between vivere (living) and bibere (drinking)
The Hispanic origin of the Latin poet seemed, therefore, enough to attribute to him a verse which is neither his nor seems consistent with the satirical intentions of this author. Besides, this would not be reason enough, because the Lusitanian (Portuguese) people also adapt it to their homeland and say about themselves:
beati Lusitani quibus vivere est bibere.
or
beati sunt Lusitani apud quos vivere est bibere
Lucky are the Portuguese for whom vivere (to live) is bibere (to drink)
And something similar is said about the Gascons, or Basques, from both sides of the Pyrenees, to whom the impulsive Julius Caesar Scaliger refers, and in whose reference lies surely the closest source of the happy expression, as we will see later.
The fact that Latin, although it was written the same everywhere, was not spoken the same in northern Africa, in Hispania, in Asia or in Germania is well attested since ancient times, but we have no evidence that the identity of sound between b and v in Hispania and in the south of France was so old. The sentence or expression “beati hispani quibus vivere est bibere” seems to reflect, then, the medieval and Renaissance pronunciation.
Anyway, puns between "vivere" and "bibere" were already being made in Antiquity, but this does not mean they were pronounced the same. An example is what Flavius Vopiscus (one of the historians of the Historia Augusta, in the third century) says about Gallus Quintus Bonosus, who proclaimed himself emperor in 281 and, curiously, had been born in Hispania, although his father was from Britain and his mother from Gaul,
Bonosus was born in Hispania (he was of Hispanic house), of British origin and
of a Gallic mother, as he himself said, son of a professor of rhetoric... he was general
of the Rhaetian frontier, and he drank more than any other man. Aurelian used to say about him: he was not born to live, but to drink.
“Bonosus domo Hispaniensi fuit, origine Britannus, Galla tamen matre, ut
ipse dicebat, rhetoris filius, … dux limitis Raetici fuit, bibit quantum
hominum nemo. de hoc Aurelianus saepe dicebat, "Non ut vivat natus est,
sed ut bibat," (Historiae Augustae, Flavius Vopiscus, Firmus Saturninus
Proculus et Bonosus, 14, 1… y 3..)
Moreover, and regardless of phonetic issues, there is also some semantic relationship between "life" and "wine", an invigorating drink of the same colour as the blood which gives us life, which may have made the pun easier. The use of wine in religious rites since the most ancient times is not unrelated to this.
But since when has there been confusion in the sounds so that the sound "v" [w] is confused with the sound [b]? In the Iberian Peninsula, among the Gascons or Basques, the phenomenon seems to go back at least to the Carolingian period.
We can get an idea of the difficulties that the diverse pronunciation of Latin caused, and not just because of the Hispanic confusion we're dealing with (on another occasion we'll discuss this issue), from the fact that the great humanist Erasmus of Rotterdam (1466-1536) devoted a treatise to this issue in 1528, the treatise “De Recta latini graecique sermonis pronuntiatione”(On the Correct Pronunciation of Latin and Greek) in which he says what follows with regard to this matter:
«Hic peccant et eruditi, vulgus autem, et qui vulgatam pronuntiationem non dedidicerunt, interdum pro b pronuntiant v consonans, et contra, ut vivit pro bibit, et bibit pro vivit. Id peculiare dicitur cuidam Hispaniarum regioni» .
Here scholars too make mistakes, and not only the common people; so do those who did not scorn the vulgar pronunciation and pronounce as "b" the consonant "v" and, conversely, when they say-"vivit" instead of "bibit" and "bibit" instead of "vivit". This peculiarity is found in a certain region of Spain
Felix natio, ubi est vivere bibere: some attribute this to Erasmus, but I have not been able to document it.
It is possibly Scaliger (1484-1558), an impulsive humanist, a native of Rocca di Riva, on Lake Garda (Italy), at odds with Erasmus, whom he despised as a Latinist, who, settled in France (he lived and died in Gascony), is the father of the expression we're dealing with "Beati hispani quibus vivere est bibere".
This humanist was called Giulio Cesare Scaligero or della Scala in Italian; in Latin, Julius Caesar Scaliger; Julio César Escalígero in Spanish; in France he called himself Jules Cesar de l'Escale de Bordonis.
This saying, as such, is not among the works of Scaliger, but he himself refers to a burlesque remark of his on the indifference with which the Gascons pronounce the "b" and the "v". He says in his work “De causis linguae latinae libri XIII "(Lyon, 1540; Geneva, 1580, reprinted in 1597), Chapter X, entitled Consonantium potestates: (p. 17 in the edition of 1540 and pages 21-22 in the edition of 1597):
This is also a vice peculiar to the Basques, because they pronounce the "B"
just as we say that the Greeks do. And so we made a joke about them (the Basques) in an epigram stating that for them vivere (living) is bibere (drinking).
Vasconibus quoque hoc est vitium peculiare, ut eo modo pronuncient B quo et
Graecos dicimus. Itaque lusimus in eos (Vascones) epigrammate ut eorum
vivere bibere sit
This epigram, which Scaliger himself refers to, is the same which was attributed to Martial, though with some small changes: non for haud, mutas for mutat
Non temere antiquas mutas, Vasconia, voces,
Cui nihil est aliud vivere quam bibere
And indeed, in his important study of poetry “Poetices Libri Septem "(Geneva, 1561; Leyden, 1581; Heidelberg, 1607), we find the following couplet...
Non temere antiquas mutat Vasconia voces
Cui nihil est aliud vivere quam bibere
It is found in Book III, p.170 of the Apud Ioannem Crispinum edition of 1561 and on page 432 of the second edition, Apud Petrum Santandreanum, 1581.
Indirectly he refers to the phonetic confusion we have already mentioned before, but not explicitly, because what he says exactly is:
Verum ut res aliae ex aliis suboriuntur, hilariora fiunt omnia ubi litterae
syllabaeve mutantur, quemadmodum nos…
Now, as some things have their origin in others, all are made
funny if you change the letters or syllables as-I did-...
and then comes the couplet quoted.
So the exact sentence "Beati hispani..." or "Beati populi...” is not, strictly speaking, found in the work of Scaliger. Most likely a disciple, acquaintance or reader of Scaliger later created the general expression from that couplet:
Beati populi quibus vivere est bibere"
or the more specific one and limited to Hispania
"Beati Hispani quibus vivere est bibere"
then repeated endlessly and attributed without any evidence to that Julius Caesar Scaliger. But it is frequently attributed to him. Thus in the “Menagiana”, Gilles Menage (1613-1692). In it we find a reference to a certain “Recueil des poesies” by Scligere. Fifty or sixty years later the abbot Moreri in his great Dictionnaire historique, Volume V, Paris 1759, in the article on Gascogne says:
"Les habitants prononcent l'V (sic) comme le B, et le B comme l'V, et c'est par cette raison que Scaliger, parlant des Gascons, a dit plaisamment "Felices populi quibus bibere est vivere".
And Abbot Pierre Adam d'Origny, in his Dictionnaire des origines, Article Gascogne, presents the expression or saying in its most usual abbreviated form (Paris 1777,
"L'habitude qu'il (ancient Basques) avaient apporté d'Espagne de confondre V et le B a fait dire a Scaliger: Felices populi quibus bibere est vivere").
Even Victor Hugo, taking advantage of his stay in Behobia, says:
"... I am in the country where people pronounce B instead of V;
at which that tippler Scaliger went into raptures: Felices populi- he exclaimed-
quibus vivere est bibere”.
There are also many quotes of the sentence in which its paternity is attributed to Julius Caesar, just like that, to the famous Gaius Julius Caesar, in an absolutely unjustified way. It would not have been a bad paternity, nor one of little authority, but I am afraid that such a gross mistake is only due to the childish confusion of the humanist Julius Caesar Scaliger with the dictator Gaius Julius Caesar, the origin of the Roman Empire, who are separated by a mere sixteen centuries.
Besides, there are numerous variants of this sentence, which basically say the same thing:
Beati Hispani quibus vivere est bibere
Beati Hispani quibus vivere bibere est
Beati Hispani quibus bibere vivere est
Beati Hispani, dum bibere dicunt vivere
O beati hispani, dum vivere dicunt bibere
There are also many variants or versions replacing "beati" with "felices". Thus:
“Felix natio, ubi vivere est bibere”, (which some attribute to Erasmus, and which probably comes from a sentence of Lipsius that we will discuss a little further on)
“O felix Iberia, ubi vivere bibere est” (the previous one, applied specifically to Spain)
"Faelices populi quibus vivere bibere est" (sentence that Manuel de Larramendi (1690-1766), priest and pioneer of Basque nationalism, attributed to Scaliger in his trilingual Dictionary of Castilian, Basque and Latin, 1745).
The only reference or quotation in the opposite sense, praising the sobriety of the Spanish people, belongs to another humanist Justus Lipsius (1547-1606), also concerned about the pronunciation of the Latin, who in his work Dialogi de recta pronuntiatione Latinae Lingvae, Caput XII, (on page 35, 1599 edition, Antverpiae, Ex officina Plantiniana, Apud Ioannem Moretum) refers to the confusion of "b" and "v" and says:
To the Hispanics and also to the Basques, who soften it and twist it towards the V digamma, sober men who do not like Bibere (Drinking) but Vivere (Living)
«Et Hispanos itemque Vascones, qui emolliunt et ad V digamma
Torquent, homines sobrii et quibus non placet Bibere sed Vivere»
In no way should we rule out a priori that it is precisely Justus Lipsius (1547-1606) and not Scaliger who is at the origin of the sentence or saying that is the subject of this article. He was born in Brabant, in the Spanish Netherlands, and therefore it does not seem baseless or idle to us to claim his role in the matter.
Whether the joke originated with Lipsius or Scaliger, or comes from remote antiquity and was adapted by each place to its own reality, as seems more likely, an idea of its success is also given by the following quotation from Don Quixote, Part Two, Chapter . XIIII, 27 (a possible translation into English could be, more or less, the following):
But even if they were filled with silk cocoons, know, sir, that I am not going to fight: let our masters fight, and that is their affair, and let us drink and live, for time itself takes care to take away our lives, without our going about looking for incentives to make them end before they reach their season and term and fall from ripeness.
In summary, the conceptual connection between living and drinking is very old; so is the connection between the Latin terms "vivere" and "bibere"; the phrase "beati hispani quibus vivere est bibere" is a creation of Renaissance Humanism.