Intellectuals and power (I): Diogenes the Cynic versus Alexander the Great
When the Greeks, applying reason, began to ask themselves what real things are, why they exist and what they are for, they gave birth to Philosophy.
History of Greece and Rome
1001 anecdotes and curiosities of the ancient world
45 articles
When the Greeks, applying reason, began to ask themselves what real things are, why they exist and what they are for, they gave birth to Philosophy.
The powerful, holders of force and violence, have generally distrusted thinkers, although they are forced to live with them. The theme of the conflictive meeting of the king and the sage is a universal commonplace.https://www.antiquitatem.com/en/diogenes-alexander-intellectual-power Plato envisioned a republic in which the rulers were philosophers, scholars, intellectuals, constituted in a caste with special education. Plato's attempt to make his theory a reality in Sicily with Dionysius the Elder and then with his son was a complete failure. Probably the king can not become a philosopher, because he would question his own condition, his own status as king, nor can the philosopher be king, because in the exercise of power he would cease to be a philosopher. Consequently it seems they are condemned to coexist.
The most famous story of the first meeting of Diogenes with Alexander later served Dio Chrysostom to recreate the meeting, to satirize power and the powerful and to present his ideas about the divine origin of power and the legitimation of its exercise.
The meaning of this Latin phrase, which has become a proverb, is to warn of how an application of the law strictly to the letter can become a huge injustice.
Respect for animals and nature in general is a very modern concern. There are not many ancient texts that involve explicit reflection on the need to respect the "environment", among other reasons because the ability to destroy or modify it was much lower and this probably made that reflection unnecessary.
The question has often been raised. Plato in his "Apology" or "Defense of Socrates" and in some dialogues and Xenophon in his "Defence of Socrates," give us enough information about how the hostile atmosphere developed that led to condemning the wisest and most just of men on the apparently flimsy accusation of three mediocre and envious fellow citizens. And it is precisely this failure and injustice that keeps alive the interest in understanding the contradiction that the first democracy in history unjustly condemned the wisest and most just of men, who courageously accepts the death penalty. Now, as a general rule, the past cannot be interpreted with the social values of the present.
There are many European citizens who are appalled by the claim of the government and of the Greek citizens themselves that a write-off be applied to the huge debt incurred in previous years. There are also other citizens who analyze the origin of that debt, which they largely consider abusive, and are more understanding. The current situation is not at all comparable with the old, but I will offer two series of texts, some referring to Solon, who faced with legal changes the untenable situation of many Athenian citizens back in the sixth century BC, indebted to the point of slavery; and other texts that reveal the particular attitude of an individual, also crushed by private debts, which is reflected for example by Aristophanes in his comedy the Clouds.
There are numerous classical texts in which the patriotism of citizens is exalted, both in Greece, where they felt very superior to the rest of the world, which they call "barbaric" because they do not speak Greek but babble, as in Rome, where they also knew they were the masters of the world.
We must be politically correct. But what does this phrase, so “hackneyed” these days, mean? It no doubt refers to the obviously hypocritical attitude with which people, especially those who perform some “political” function, must behave before citizens, expressing only what their listeners want to hear or at least what does not arouse their opposition.
Caesar Augustus died on 19 August of the year 14 AD, at about four in the afternoon . It's been two thousand years since then. Caesar Augustus had a long reign and he had a peaceful, untroubled death, unlike a number of his successors who suffered a violent death. had a peaceful, untroubled death, unlike a number of his successors who suffered a violent death.